How to Choose the Right Seat Cover Material: Leather vs. Leatherette vs. Cloth

When it’s time to replace your car’s seat covers, one of the first decisions you’ll face is which material to choose. Leather, vinyl, and cloth are the three most common options, and each comes with its own advantages, feel, and price point.

If you're shopping for OEM-style replacement seat covers, the material you select will affect not only your interior's look, but also your comfort, maintenance routine, and overall driving experience.

Here’s a breakdown to help you choose the right one for your lifestyle and budget.

Leather Seat Covers

Best for: Luxury look, comfort, resale value

Pros:

Premium look and feel

Naturally soft and breathable

Increases resale value of your vehicle

Long-lasting when properly maintained

Cons:

Higher cost

Requires regular cleaning and conditioning

Ideal for: Drivers who want to upgrade their interior or maintain a luxury vehicle’s original aesthetic. Leather is a great choice for cars like BMW, Mercedes-Benz, Lexus, or higher trims of trucks and SUVs.

Leatherette Seat Covers

Best for: Durability, low maintenance, affordability

Pros:

Easy to clean, just wipe with a damp cloth

Water-resistant and stain-resistant

More affordable than leather

Great for work vehicles or families with kids/pets

Cons:

Not as soft or premium-feeling as leather

Ideal for: Work trucks, commercial vehicles, or anyone who prioritizes function over form. If your vehicle sees a lot of mess, leatherette is your best friend.

Cloth Seat Covers

Best for: Everyday comfort, breathability, budget-conscious buyers

Pros:

Soft, comfortable, and breathable in all climates

Typically more affordable than leather

Less temperature-sensitive

Available in many colors and textures

Cons:

Absorbs stains and odors more easily

Harder to clean than vinyl or leather

Ideal for: Daily commuters, families, and anyone who wants a practical and comfortable ride without breaking the bank.

Our Recommendation

If you’re restoring a high-end or classic vehicle and want to maintain that original feel, go with OEM-style leather. If you need something tough, easy to clean, and budget-friendly, vinyl is a solid choice. And if comfort and affordability are your priorities, you can’t go wrong with cloth.

Ultimately, the right material depends on how you use your vehicle, and what matters most to you: appearance, comfort, maintenance, or cost.